Skip to content
  • About Us
    • Who We Serve
  • Solutions
    • HIPAA for Covered Entities
    • OSHA for Healthcare
    • HIPAA for Business Associates
    • SRA for Covered Entities
    • Abyde Incident Response Program
    • Abyde Reseller Program
  • Resources
  • News
  • Events
  • Partners
  • Contact Us
  • Login
    • HIPAA for Covered Entities
    • OSHA for Healthcare
    • HIPAA for Business Associates
    • SRA for Covered Entities
SIGN UP
BOOK A DEMO

OCR Continues HIPAA Right of Access Fine Streak, Announces 12th Settlement

November 19, 2020

Reporting new HIPAA settlements has become a weekly routine this month (we’ve got our calendars marked for next week’s already), and after today’s announcement on the Office for Civil Rights (OCR) 12th right of access initiative settlement (the third in November), we now have enough patient right of access fines to last us a whole year.

This week’s HIPAA headline goes to the University of Cincinnati Medical Center, LLC (UCMC), an academic medical center that provides healthcare services to the Greater Cincinnati Community. UCMC agreed to a $65,000 payout as well as a 2-year corrective action plan with the OCR to settle a violation of (you guessed it) the HIPAA right of access standard. 

The by-now familiar story began back in May of 2019, when the OCR received a complaint that UCMC failed to respond to a patient’s request that her electronic health records (EHR) be sent directly to her lawyers on February 22, 2019. After further investigation and a little push from the OCR, the medical center finally provided the requested records in August of that year. 

While we’ve seen more than a handful (2 handfuls plus two fingers to be exact) of patient right of access fines over the past year, this specific settlement is a great example of not only failing to provide patient records in a timely manner, but also in the proper format they were requested in. It is required under HIPAA law to be able to provide patients with a copy of their records in the format they request – either in paper or electronic form – as well as have the ability to transmit records directly to a third party if specified. If it isn’t possible to provide records the way a patient requests, the covered entity must agree to an alternative method with the requester.

Emphasizing the importance of providing records in the format requested, OCR Director Roger Severino added that the “OCR is committed to enforcing patients’ right to access their medical records, including the right to direct electronic copies to a third party of their choice. HIPAA covered entities should review their policies and training programs to ensure they know and can fulfill all their HIPAA obligations whenever a patient seeks access to his or her records.” 

Today’s settlement brings the running count of 2020 HIPAA fines to a total of $13,291,500 with 6 weeks still left in the year. If the weekly fine trend continues, we could expect at least 6 more HIPAA settlements and a whole lot of $$$ to come rolling in before 2020 finally ends. While we’re all looking forward to 2020 calling it quits, 6 more fines would blow 2019’s enforcement records out of the water. 

With annual HIPAA deadlines right around the corner and weekly examples of why you should ensure your practice is compliant, we couldn’t think of a better time to add HIPAA to the top of your to-do list!

RECENT POSTS

  • Dental Practice HIPAA Settlement
    What Every Dental Practice Can Learn From the $140K Shen Smiles Settlement
  • Ambry Phishing Settlement
    $700K HIPAA Settlement: What the Ambry Genetics Phishing Breach Teaches Every Practice
  • Azul Vision Right of Access
    Right of Access Enforcement Hits Eye Care: Inside the Azul Vision Settlement
PrevPreviousMaryland Optometric Association and Abyde deliver HIPAA compliance to independent eye care professionals
NextWhat You Need to Know About HIPAA Patient Right of Access LawsNext

Related posts

Dental Practice HIPAA Settlement
Abyde News, Fines, HIPAA

What Every Dental Practice Can Learn From the $140K Shen Smiles Settlement

October 9, 2026 Penelope Schweitzer No comments yet

October 9, 2026 The latest HIPAA settlement doesn’t involve a hospital system or a massive ransomware attack. It involves a practice that probably looks a lot like yours. Shen Smiles is a solo dental practice in Drums, Pennsylvania. It started with a former patient’s complaint about getting their health records. It led to a broader OCR investigation and a $140,000 settlement. The lesson? Every HIPAA-regulated organization, big or small, can face enforcement.   What happened? Under federal law, patients must be given access to their records within 30 days, with one possible 30-day extension if the patient is notified in writing within the first 30 days. In April 2020, a former patient’s attorney filed a complaint with the Office for Civil Rights (OCR). The complaint alleged that the patient had requested their records multiple times without receiving access. The public documents don’t say when the first request was made. OCR’s investigation went beyond the original complaint. According to the resolution agreement, OCR found that patient records weren’t properly maintained and that staff hadn’t received formal HIPAA Privacy Rule training. OCR also said the practice couldn’t produce evidence that it had HIPAA policies and procedures in place, including for patient access requests, or that it had reasonably safeguarded patient information. During the investigation, the practice stated that it couldn’t provide the records because a workforce member had stolen them. The public documents don’t address whether a breach assessment was done. As a general rule, though, HIPAA presumes that an impermissible acquisition, access, use, or disclosure of unsecured patient information is a breach. A breach can require notifying HHS and affected patients, including steps patients can take to protect themselves. These are baseline requirements every covered entity is expected to have in place. Policies and training give a team a HIPAA playbook. Without one, staff at any practice may not know what to do when a patient asks for records or records go missing. OCR proposed a $140,000 civil money penalty in July 2024. Shen Smiles requested a hearing before an administrative law judge, but the two sides reached a resolution agreement in August 2026, before the hearing took place. Under the agreement, the practice agreed to pay $140,000. The agreement is not an admission of liability.   The Takeaway for Practices Patient access has been an OCR priority for years through its HIPAA Right of Access Initiative, and this case marks its 56th Right of Access enforcement action. It also took more than six years from complaint to resolution. As this case shows, a single complaint can lead to a broader look at your compliance program. Now is the time to ask: Do we have written HIPAA policies our team can find? Do we have a process to answer every record request within 30 days? Can we prove every team member has completed HIPAA training? If any of those gave you pause, now’s the time to fix it, before OCR comes asking. Looking for the first step? Meet with one of our compliance experts to see where you currently stand. 

Ambry Phishing Settlement
Abyde News, Fines, HIPAA

$700K HIPAA Settlement: What the Ambry Genetics Phishing Breach Teaches Every Practice

September 21, 2026 Penelope Schweitzer No comments yet

September 21, 2026   The HHS Office for Civil Rights (OCR) has announced its biggest HIPAA settlement of the year, reaching nearly a million dollars.  Ambry, a genetic testing and clinical genomics provider based in Aliso Viejo, California is at the center of this enforcement. A settlement was reached over a 2020 phishing attack that exposed the Protected Health Information (PHI) of more than 225,000 individuals. This settlement is a clear reminder that even large organizations trip up on HIPAA requirements.    What happened In January 2020, an employee email account at Ambry was compromised through a phishing attack.  The breach potentially exposed a wide range of PHI, including names, addresses, dates of birth, Social Security Numbers, financial details, and more. Ambry reported the breach to OCR in March 2020, which kicked off the investigation.    Where OCR found gaps OCR’s investigation identified several HIPAA Security Rule gaps, including: No accurate, thorough risk analysis of risks and vulnerabilities to ePHI No process for cutting off access to ePHI when an employee left or no longer needed access No unique user IDs for tracking who was accessing ePHI systems These are baseline HIPAA requirements that every Covered Entity and Business Associate is expected to have in place.   The settlement terms Ambry paid $700,000 and agreed to a two-year corrective action plan, under which it must: Complete a thorough risk analysis of ePHI confidentiality, integrity, and availability Build and execute a risk management plan addressing what that analysis turns up Review and update Security Rule policies and procedures as needed Implement unique user identification across all ePHI systems Train the whole workforce on those updated policies The takeaway for practices When 90% of healthcare hacks start with a successful phishing attempt, it’s key your team is aware of the role they play to keep data safe. Every practice should ask; Do we know exactly where our ePHI lives and how it moves through our systems? Do we have a current, documented risk analysis? Would we catch it fast if a former employee’s access wasn’t revoked? Looking for the first step of addressing these gaps? Meet with one of our compliance experts to see where you currently stand. 

Azul Vision Right of Access
Abyde News, Fines, HIPAA

Right of Access Enforcement Hits Eye Care: Inside the Azul Vision Settlement

September 1, 2026 Penelope Schweitzer No comments yet

September 1, 2026   The Office for Civil Rights (OCR) announced its 55th settlement under the HIPAA Right of Access Initiative, and this one is a good reminder that “we’ll get to it” is an easy shortcut to a massive financial penalty.   What happened Azul Vision, Inc., a California optometry enterprise healthcare provider, took nearly two years to provide a patient her healthcare records failed to give a patient timely access to her health records. She requested her records in January 2023. She didn’t actually receive them until January 2025, or two years later, and only after OCR opened an investigation following her complaint in April 2023.   The importance of Right of Access The HIPAA Privacy Rule’s Right of Access is straightforward: patients are entitled to their healthcare records within 30 days of a request, with one possible 30-day extension if needed.    The cost Azul Vision agreed to a two-year, OCR-monitored corrective action plan and paid $50,000. The corrective action plan requires the practice to: Review and revise its written policies and procedures for Privacy Rule compliance.  Regularly report to HHS a log of every PHI access request it receives, including when it came in and when it was resolved, Train all workforce members on right of access requirements and the practice’s own procedures.   Practical takeaways Have a documented, assigned process for access requests: not an informal “someone will handle it” arrangement. Track every request against the 30-day (or extended 60-day) clock: If nothing is timestamping requests, nothing is catching the ones that slip. Train staff specifically on right of access: this is a distinct Privacy Rule obligation from general HIPAA awareness, and it’s clearly one OCR is actively enforcing.   The bottom line A single records request that went unanswered turned into a $50,000 penalty, two years of federal monitoring, and a detrimental hit to the organization’s reputation. That’s a steep price for what really comes down to a missing process. If your team can’t answer “what happens the moment a patient asks for their records?” right now, that’s the gap to close before your practice ends up as OCR’s next enforcement case. Want a streamlined way to close your compliance gaps? Meet with an Abyde expert today!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
Abyde Logo

1.800.594.0883 | info@abyde.com

Automated HIPAA and OSHA Compliance

Our Reviews

From Our Blog
  • Don’t Get Caught Off Guard: HIPAA Audits are Back!
  • Don’t Be a Statistic: Why OSHA Compliance Matters in Healthcare
  • What Money Doesn’t Cover: The True Price of HIPAA Non-Compliance
  • HIPAA: It’s Not Just a Training – Your Guide to Continuous Compliance
Solutions
  • HIPAA for Covered Entities
  • OSHA for Healthcare
  • HIPAA for Business Associates
  • SRA for Covered Entities
  • Abyde Incident Response Program
  • Abyde Reseller Program
Resources
  • News
  • Events
  • Partners
  • HIPAA Badges
  • OSHA Badges
  • Learning Center
  • Compliance FAQs
Company
  • About Us
  • Who We Serve
  • Pricing
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • Jobs
  • COPYRIGHT © 2026 ABYDE
  • |

  • TERMS & CONDITIONS
  • |

  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • |

  • SECURITY MEASURES
  • |

  • E-SIGNATURE TERMS