September 23, 2020 The Office for Civil Rights has been dropping fines left and right in the last week, releasing their 7th (and largest) HIPAA settlement earlier today and bringing their running total to seven fines in just 8 days. The latest violation came with a hefty payout of $2.3 million as well as an extensive 2-year corrective action plan – and not to mention a whole lot of apology letters to write. The lucky winner of the latest HIPAA settlement is CHSPSC LLC, a business associate who serves a number of hospitals and clinics owned by Community Health Systems, Inc out of Tennessee. You may be thinking, “well no biggie, I’m a covered entity not a business associate so that wouldn’t be me,” but the 6 million+ patients affected and the reasons the OCR gave for levying a fine would beg to differ. Just like any covered entity might be, this business associate was the victim of a cyberattack that even after alarms were raised went unmitigated for months. As if that wasn’t enough, the OCR investigation discovered long standing non-compliance with the HIPAA Security Rule ultimately landing the business associate at the top of the most expensive 2020 fines list. On April 10, 2014, CHSPSC’s information system was infiltrated by a threat group that went unnoticed until the company was notified by the FBI 8 days later. The hackers continued to have a field-day, accessing the sensitive data for 4 months after the initial attack. CHSPSC’s continued disregard for implementing the necessary security protections required by HIPAA even AFTER receiving federal notice was described by OCR Director, Roger Severino, as “inexcusable”. The cyberattack affected 237 different covered entities served by CHSPSC and withdrew the PHI of 6,121,158 individuals including everything from names and birthdays to emergency contact information and social security numbers. As if over 6 million patients records being taken wasn’t bad enough, an OCR investigation into the business associate found several gaps in their compliance program including: It doesn’t matter whether you’re a healthcare provider, business associate, or just the average joe – falling victim to a cyberattack is fair game. Because business associates require the same HIPAA safeguard requirements as covered entities, no matter who gets hacked the OCR is looking for the same requirements and can hand out the same fines for either type of health related entity. For providers especially, entrusting your patients sensitive data to your business associates comes with added risks. In this case, 237 covered entities had to find that out the hard way. While there’s no way to be 100% in the clear from things like cyber attacks, having the proper business associate agreements in place at least takes the liability of an incident off your practice’s hands. If you had been one of those 237 entities affected here, lack of an agreement could have put your practice on the same chopping block as CHSPSC.
